Hollow Horn Bear

1923

Created by theLakotaDev

Hollow Horn Bear

Sicangu Lakota, c. 1850 – March 15, 1913. The full account, with sources.

1850–1855

Born in the smallpox winter

He was born in March 1850, by the oldest records, in country that later maps would call Sheridan County, Nebraska, near the Niobrara River. There was no Nebraska then. The territory came four years later. His great-grandson, Duane Hollow Horn Bear, gives the year as 1851, the year of the first treaty at Fort Laramie.

His father was Iron Shell, son of Bull Tail and leader of the Orphan band of the Sicangu. His mother was Wants Everything. He was one of a large family.

The keepers of the Brulé winter counts named each year for one thing that happened in it, and painted it. Battiste Good’s count names the winter he was born for the smallpox. The next winter is the “First-issue-of-goods winter”: the first annuities promised by the 1851 treaty.

Sources for this chapter
  • Probable Born March 1850, Sheridan County. Hodge, Handbook of American Indians (1907), p. 557; Curtis, The North American Indian vol. 3 (1908), p. 186; his own 1909 interview (age 59).
  • Disputed 1851, per American National Biography (2000), entry by Duane Hollow Horn Bear.
  • Confirmed Iron Shell, son of Bull Tail, Orphan band. Bettelyoun & Waggoner, With My Own Eyes (1998), p. 154 n. 7.
  • Confirmed Winter names. Mallery, Picture-Writing of the American Indians (1893), figs. 407–408.

Blue Water

On the morning of September 3, 1855, General William S. Harney’s troops attacked Little Thunder’s Brulé camp on Blue Water Creek, near Ash Hollow. Iron Shell’s camp was there.

The trader James Bordeaux had sent word twice that Harney was coming. Iron Shell told the people they would put up a white flag and talk, and he rode out with Little Thunder to meet the soldiers. By Harney’s own count, 86 Lakota were killed and about 70 women and children were taken prisoner. Battiste Good’s count says 130 died.

The youngest of Iron Shell’s three wives was taken to Fort Laramie. She was later carried east by a discharged soldier, “never to be heard from again.”

What happened to the boy is told three ways.

If he was born in 1850, he was five that September, not a baby. The record does not settle it.

Sources for this chapter
  • Confirmed The attack, Bordeaux’s warnings, the white flag, Harney’s figures. Bettelyoun & Waggoner (1998); Paul Beck, The First Sioux War (2004).
  • Confirmed Iron Shell’s youngest wife taken and never returned. Bettelyoun & Waggoner (1998), p. 154 n. 7. Wikipedia, citing Sprague, says two wives.
  • Disputed What happened to Hollow Horn Bear: three versions, above.
  • Confirmed Winter name. Mallery (1893), fig. 412.

1859–1875

Making the name good

At about nine he was a guest at Crow Dog’s wedding. He said so under oath in 1882, at the trial that followed Crow Dog’s killing of Spotted Tail.

At twelve he went with his first war party, against the Pawnee. At sixteen he rode with his father’s party against the Pawnee near what is now Genoa, Nebraska.

In April 1868 his father signed the treaty at Fort Laramie, first among the Brulé, as Ma-za-pon-kaska. Forty-three years later the son still held to it.

The 1868 Treaty, a man, my father, made that treaty.

Hollow Horn Bear, Rosebud, November 1, 1911

At nineteen he carried the pipe and led a party of his own against Pawnee wood-haulers, and struck his first coup. His father wanted him to take the name Iron Shell. He refused. Edward Curtis wrote down what he said:

he would take his grandfather’s name instead, and make the name Hollow Horn Bear good.

As recorded by Edward S. Curtis, 1908

Which grandfather first carried the name is not recorded.

Sources for this chapter
  • Probable Crow Dog’s wedding at about nine. His 1882 testimony, via Harring, Crow Dog’s Case.
  • Probable First war party at 12; first coup at 19; the name. Curtis vol. 3 (1908), p. 186, from his own account.
  • Probable Pawnee near Genoa at 16. Hodge (1907), p. 557.
  • Confirmed Iron Shell’s signature, April 29, 1868. Treaty text, NARA NAID 299803.
  • Confirmed “my father, made that treaty.” McLaughlin council minutes, Nov. 1, 1911, reprinted in the record of Rosebud Sioux Tribe v. Kneip (1977).

Twenty-three fights

By his own count he fought twenty-three times: against the Pawnee, Omaha, Ponca, Shoshoni, Ute, Arikara and United States troops. Writers after his death made it thirty-one.

A 1907 biography has him fighting soldiers in Wyoming and Montana in 1868, and joining a raid on the crews building the Union Pacific Railroad in 1869. No report from the time has been found to confirm either.

Popular books put him at the Fetterman fight in December 1866. He was sixteen, and no early source places him there.

In the winter of 1871–72 he hunted with Spotted Tail’s people on the Republican River. In 1874 he married Good Bed, daughter of Conquering Bear. American National Biography says they had seven children. That winter the Brulé count remembers the Utes running off the horses.

Sources for this chapter
  • Probable Twenty-three fights. Curtis vol. 3 (1908), p. 186, his own account. The “31 battles” comes from a 1913 obituary.
  • Probable 1868 and 1869 raids. Hodge (1907) only.
  • Myth Fetterman fight. Thrapp, Encyclopedia of Frontier Biography (1988): “too young.”
  • Confirmed Republican River hunt: subpoenaed in U.S. v. Coe, Carter & Bratt (1877). Nebraska History 15 (1934).
  • Confirmed Good Bed, daughter of Conquering Bear, married 1874. American National Biography.

1876

The Greasy Grass

In June 1909 Hollow Horn Bear answered the battle historian Walter M. Camp’s printed questions about the fight, through an interpreter, to Camp’s agent Sewell B. Weston. Weston wrote the answers down in English, often in the third person (“Witness states…”). The statement is in the Walter Camp Collection at Little Bighorn Battlefield, and is printed in Richard G. Hardorff, Lakota Recollections of the Custer Fight (1991), pp. 177–186.

Before the fight

Hollow Horn Bear had some horses that had either strayed or were stolen. He, in company with about 20 Two Kettle Indians, was out looking for these horses. While at Heart Creek, a branch of the Yellowstone, he first saw soldiers. This was in the latter part of May or the 1st of June. The Soldiers were headed westward. He states that he was informed that this was Custer’s outfit. This bunch followed the soldiers for two days and then cut across to the Greasy Grass and joined Sitting Bull.

p. 178. Camp added that the stream was probably the Heart River, a Missouri tributary on Custer’s line of march.

He was in the camp about five days before the fight. Of the Brulé camp:

About 65 tepees, and 30 warriors.

p. 179

Hardorff places the Brulé lodges “adjacent to the Oglala circle,” in the north-west part of the village. Every source puts the Hunkpapa at the south end and the Cheyenne at the north. Between them the sources differ; the drawing follows the order Walter Camp’s 1909 questionnaire gives from the south (“Uncpapa, Blackfeet, Sans Arc”), then the Minneconjou, the Oglala and the Brulé. Another 1909 informant added that a few Arapaho lodges stood between the Oglala and the Brulé.

June 25

Witness was at the Brule village and first saw the soldiers over the top of the high ridge at about “E” [Nye-Cartwright Ridge].

p. 180

Yes. Was among the first to cross the river. Some of the young warriors rode back and forth in front of Custer’s front before any real change [charge] was made. None of these were killed, a good omen that the Indians would win the day. Most of the Indians were mounted; a good many however, were afoot.

p. 180

Soldiers never made a charge. Soldiers kept together all during the fight.

The soldiers kept moving all the time. Witness states that the soldiers were drunk. (Demoralized.)

p. 182. The historian Richard Fox reads “drunk” as a figure of speech for panic.

The fighting was at close quarters. This witness used his war club at this point.

p. 183, on Custer Hill

He did not see at any time any of the soldiers make a rush to get away. Said they were all brave men.

p. 184

Just a few minutes. (Witness could not tell whether one or ten.)

p. 184, asked how long the last stand lasted

June 26

Reno had burrowed in the ground like a prairie dog. Guns and arrows could not reach him.

p. 185

Indians were all in as far as the fighting was concerned. They had got enough.

p. 186

Asked how many fell in all the camps, he gave what he had heard: “Six killed and six wounded; the latter all recovered.” The National Park Service now estimates 60 to 100 Lakota and Cheyenne dead, and 268 soldiers, civilians and scouts with the Seventh Cavalry. Hardorff notes that none of the Lakota dead were reported to be Brulé.

Edward Curtis, from a separate interview published in 1908: “He was present at the Custer fight.”

Sources for this chapter
  • Confirmed His 1909 statement to Weston for Walter Camp. Hardorff, Lakota Recollections of the Custer Fight (Arthur H. Clark, 1991), pp. 177–186. Text recovered from the book; not yet checked against the page images.
  • Confirmed Curtis, The North American Indian vol. 3 (1908), p. 186.
  • Confirmed Casualties: National Park Service, Little Bighorn Battlefield National Monument.
  • Probable The camp circles: Hardorff (1991), notes to the statement.
  • Red Horse (Minneconjou Lakota) drew the camp and the battle in 1881; the drawings were published by the Bureau of Ethnology in 1893.
  • A family account: his grandson Albert White Hat Sr. told the historian Herman Viola that “Hollow Horn Bear was not in the battle. He was out scouting somewheres. However, he told my mother about it.” Viola, Little Bighorn Remembered (1999), pp. 80–81.
  • Not to be confused with Hollow Horn Eagle, a different Brulé man whose account of the battle is in the same literature. No record credits Hollow Horn Bear with killing Custer or any named man.

1877–1878

The walk to Rosebud

In September 1877 he went to Washington with Spotted Tail, Red Cloud and twenty other leaders to protest an order moving their agencies to the Missouri River. That same month Crazy Horse was killed at Camp Robinson.

In October the Spotted Tail people reached the old Ponca Agency on the Missouri. They wintered there, complaining, in the agent’s words, of “alkaline water and scarcity of wood.” In July 1878 Spotted Tail told the commissioners he would burn the agency buildings and leave in ten days.

They started west on July 25. On September 1, 1878, they reached Rosebud Creek, “footsore and weary (many had walked all the way),” in the government agent’s own words. The agency took the creek’s name.

A 1962 state marker on Cut Meat Creek, west of the agency, marks where Hollow Horn Bear Village stood.

Sources for this chapter

1881–1891

One law

On August 5, 1881, Crow Dog shot Spotted Tail on the road near the agency. The families settled it by Lakota law. Crow Dog’s people gave Spotted Tail’s eight horses, fifty dollars and a blanket.

The government did not accept that. Henry Lelar, the clerk in charge of the agency, ordered Crow Dog arrested. Hollow Horn Bear, an officer of the Indian police, brought him in.

Mr. Lelar gave me a paper for the arrest of Crow Dog. Found defendant on a hill between White River and Rosebud Creek, where I made the arrest. Defendant had no clothes at the time, except a blanket, breechclout, and leggings and was on horseback. I did as I was ordered and took defendant to Fort Niobara [sic].

His testimony, Deadwood, March 1882

Crow Dog was convicted at Deadwood. In November 1883 the agent sent Hollow Horn Bear, unarmed, to bring him back to court. Crow Dog told him:

It is all right now you come to me without arms. Had you come armed, either you or I would die.

Press and Daily Dakotaian, December 1, 1883

On December 17, 1883, the Supreme Court set Crow Dog free. A federal court, it said, could not judge the Lakota “by a standard made by others and not for them.” Congress answered in 1885 with the Major Crimes Act. It is still law today.

Payroll records list him as a lieutenant of police in 1883 and a first sergeant in 1887. He remembered it this way:

I was a captain of police and there was one law. I only used to arrest the guilty party and no one else.

Rosebud, March 2, 1891
Sources for this chapter
  • Confirmed Lakota settlement: eight horses, $50 and a blanket. Clow, South Dakota History (2007).
  • Disputed Who made the arrest. His testimony and Clow (2007) say he took Crow Dog to Fort Niobrara on Aug. 7, 1881. The agent’s 1881 report names Eagle Hawk, captain of police. Most likely he made it serving under Eagle Hawk.
  • Confirmed Ex parte Crow Dog, 109 U.S. 556 (1883).
  • Confirmed Lieutenant, July 1, 1883: Official Register 1883, p. 579. First sergeant, July 1, 1887: Official Register 1887, pp. 563–64.
  • Confirmed “one law.” Evening Star, March 9, 1891.

The orator

In 1888 commissioners came offering fifty cents an acre for Lakota land. At Lower Brulé, as a Rosebud policeman, he answered them.

You showed us 50 cents an acre for that land, and I have thought over it, and I consider that will not take us very far. … How much money will be left for us? Maybe 5 or 10 cents. What benefit will that be to us?

Lower Brulé, September 25, 1888

It seems as if nothing that we get from the Government really belongs to us.

The same council

In June 1889 General George Crook brought a new commission to Rosebud. The newspapers called Hollow Horn Bear “the recognized leader of the opposition” and “the orator of this tribe.” Crook praised him for “his brains and oratory.”

I want to know what has become of the money? The cattle were many and the money was paid. Was the money spent here or did it go to Washington? If I knew I would not ask, but I do not.

Rosebud, June 1889

A reporter wrote that he spoke of “the hope to have only a grave in the land he now owned.” On the night of June 8 he withdrew his opposition and signed. His brother-in-law Luther Standing Bear later wrote that Hollow Horn Bear “really believed in it all the time, but that his band did not. They had asked him to be their spokesman.”

The Sioux Act broke the Great Sioux Reservation into six and opened about nine million acres to settlers.

Sources for this chapter
  • Confirmed 1888 speeches. S. Ex. Doc. 17, 50th Cong., 2d sess., pp. 207–208, 224.
  • Confirmed “What has become of the money?” Hot Springs Star, June 21, 1889.
  • Confirmed “Leader of the opposition,” signing on June 8. Helena Independent, June 9, 1889; The Sun (Morris, Minn.), June 13, 1889.
  • Probable Luther Standing Bear, My People the Sioux (1928), a memoir.
  • Still to read: the full Crook Commission transcript, S. Ex. Doc. 51, 51st Cong., 1st sess.

“Great Father, we are starving”

By the fall of 1890 the beef ration at Rosebud had been cut. On November 6, his name at the head of the letter and 102 others under it, the men of Rosebud wrote to the President.

Great Father, we are starving, and beg you, therefore, to give to us just so (as you have promised). Thirty men of us get for eighteen days (only) one cow to eat … send me (Hollow Horn Bear) traveling money and I will come with five men.

Rosebud, November 6, 1890

That winter the Ghost Dance reached Rosebud. He spoke against it, and the agent counted him among the leaders who stayed away from the Stronghold. On December 29 the Seventh Cavalry killed more than two hundred Lakota men, women and children at Wounded Knee, on Pine Ridge. Nothing places him there.

In February 1891 he went to Washington and condemned the killings to the Secretary of the Interior. Back home, Army officers questioned him about what he had said.

There was but a little handful of Indians. They could have taken them into the agency and there disarmed them, but they wanted to kill them—women and children. When I heard of that I thought about Gen. Crook. I was sure that he would have come here without troops and settled the matter.

Rosebud, March 2, 1891

My friends, look at the graves upon that hill. Open them and see if any of the bodies in them have any flesh on them. They starved to death.

To the Pearce Commission, Rosebud, July 23, 1891
Sources for this chapter
  • Confirmed The petition. Waterbury Evening Democrat, Dec. 5, 1890.
  • Confirmed Counted with the “progressive element.” Agent J. George Wright, Evening Star, Jan. 26, 1891. Probable Spoke against the dance: Luther Standing Bear (1928).
  • Confirmed Questioned by officers. Evening Star, March 9, 1891.
  • Confirmed “Look at the graves.” S. Ex. Doc. 58, 52d Cong., 1st sess., pp. 113–115.
  • Photograph: C. M. Bell, “Full delegation of Sioux Indians, 1891,” Library of Congress. The family should confirm the face.

1891–1904

For our children

Through the 1890s the question was land again: whether Rosebud should take in Lower Brulé families, and on what terms. He held one position for seven years. No one would come onto Rosebud land without the three-fourths vote the law required, and without fair payment.

That land is given to me and is mine. The land is mine and I will hold it until somebody wants to buy it.

Rosebud, March 8, 1892

In September 1895 the agency cut what it paid Lakota freighters to haul goods from Valentine, from fifty cents a hundred pounds to twenty-five. He led the protest. On September 13 the agent locked him in the guardhouse.

On the Fourth of July, 1897, the agency held its celebration. A wire report names Hollow Horn Bear among the chiefs who rode that day in a staged “Custer battle.”

The President has not paid us for other lands, and we will not sell more. We need our land.

To Senator W. V. Allen, 1897

His father, Iron Shell, died around 1896 and was buried near St. Francis. In March 1898 Hollow Horn Bear signed the Lower Brulé agreement, and so did his son John.

Sources for this chapter
  • Confirmed 1892: S. Rep. 1275, 52d Cong., 2d sess., p. 13.
  • Confirmed Jailed Sept. 13, 1895, over freight rates. Morning News, Sept. 9 and 15, 1895; Topeka State Journal, Sept. 11, 1895.
  • Confirmed 1897: The Sun (New York), Sept. 3, 1897.
  • Probable The sham “Custer battle,” July 4, 1897. Topeka State Journal, July 9, 1897 (one wire report).
  • Confirmed 1898 quote and signatures. H. Doc. 447, 55th Cong., 2d sess., pp. 16, 28.
  • Probable Iron Shell’s death in 1896. Only weak sources give the date.

A prisoner in my own country

In 1898 the Omaha studio of Frank Rinehart photographed the leaders who came to the Indian Congress at the Trans-Mississippi Exposition. These were the first portraits of him to travel widely. A railroad printed one on its 1900 calendar.

In 1901 he led about fifty Brulé people to a summer “Indian village” at Glen Island, New York.

In 1903 the government came for the eastern end of the reservation, Gregory County. He was the principal speaker.

We are Indians yet, and we remember the laws that have been made for us. The Great Father has made a law that there must be three-fourths of the people consenting before any action shall be taken by Congress. … If they do, I shall feel like a prisoner in my own country.

Rosebud, August 8, 1903

As I said before if the Great Father don’t want to pay for the land, let him keep his money, and we will keep our land.

The same day

Congress opened Gregory County in April 1904 without the consent of three-fourths of the men. That December, with rations ended, he wrote to the agent about the log house he had built, forty feet long, and the buggy and two gray horses he had bought.

Sources for this chapter
  • Confirmed Rinehart portraits, Library of Congress (2005689600, 91722606); Boston Public Library. His attendance at the Indian Congress itself is probable.
  • Confirmed Glen Island, 1901. New-York Tribune, June 15, 1901.
  • Confirmed 1903 councils. McLaughlin minutes, reprinted in the record of Rosebud Sioux Tribe v. Kneip, App. pp. 467–522.
  • Confirmed Gregory County opened: Act of April 23, 1904 (33 Stat. 254).
  • Confirmed Letter of December 1904. Black Hills Union, Dec. 16, 1904; Brookings Register, Dec. 15, 1904.

1905

Six riders

On March 3, 1905, at Carlisle Indian School in Pennsylvania, he spoke to the students.

Now my children, I am sorry that I have never had a chance to go to school and learn the way of the white people as you have now… I had a child and I sent it here to this school… In the old times a man was made great by fighting but now it is schooling that makes a man great.

Carlisle, March 3, 1905. Interpreted by Thomas Flood.

The next day he rode in Theodore Roosevelt’s inaugural parade, one of six leaders at the head of the Carlisle cadets: Geronimo, Quanah Parker, Buckskin Charlie, American Horse, Little Plume and Hollow Horn Bear.

On March 8 De Lancey Gill photographed him for the Smithsonian’s Bureau of American Ethnology. One of those glass plates, negative 3159-A, became the 14-cent stamp eighteen years later. The plate is broken now. On March 9 he was presented to the President.

Sources for this chapter
  • Confirmed Carlisle speech and the parade. The Arrow, March 9, 1905.
  • Confirmed Gill negatives 3158–3161, March 8, 1905. Smithsonian National Anthropological Archives.
  • Confirmed Presented to Roosevelt, March 9. San Francisco Call, March 10, 1905.

1906–1912

Born right here

In the winter of 1906–07 the government came for Tripp County. He spoke for his camp, with a written proxy from every adult in it, and asked five dollars an acre, then six.

I did not come from any place as a prisoner, but was born and grew up here.

Rosebud, December 19, 1906

He signed first. Congress opened Tripp County in March 1907. Mellette County followed in 1910.

About 1907 the family was baptized Catholic. He took the name Daniel; Good Bed became Susie. In 1909 he was in Washington again, to recover about $306,000 in land money withheld from Lakota children, and President Roosevelt received the delegation. In 1910 he won four prizes at the first Rosebud fair.

In November 1911 the government asked for Todd County.

I have been a party to all the treaties that have been made on this reservation… I live right here, born right here, but I am not here as a prisoner… Whatever land is left in Todd County, leave it alone, we want it ourselves.

Rosebud, November 1, 1911

Todd County was not opened. It is Rosebud today.

Sources for this chapter
  • Confirmed Councils of 1906–07, 1909 and 1911. McLaughlin minutes, record of Rosebud Sioux Tribe v. Kneip, App. pp. 776–913, 1014 ff., 1290–95.
  • Confirmed Acts of March 2, 1907 (34 Stat. 1230) and May 30, 1910 (36 Stat. 448).
  • Confirmed 1909 delegation. Washington Times, Feb. 8, 1909.
  • Probable Baptism about 1907; Daniel and Susie. American National Biography.
  • Confirmed Curtis portrait, Library of Congress; Northwestern University.
  • Map: county outlines from the U.S. Census; opening years from the Acts above.

1913

The last journey

In early February 1913 he wrote, through a senator, asking to come to Washington and give the new President a pipe.

The printed program for the February 22 groundbreaking of the National American Indian Memorial, on Staten Island, named him its orator. He was to turn the first earth “with the thigh bone of a buffalo.” A wire story that day said he did. The Washington Evening Star said he only reached the city on March 1, called by telegram. Whether he was in New York is still open.

On March 1 De Lancey Gill photographed him again. They are his last portraits.

On March 4 he led the “Representative American Indian Chiefs” at the head of the civic division of Woodrow Wilson’s inaugural parade, just ahead of Tammany Hall. A wire report says he gave the President “a peace pipe made from South Dakota red clay.”

For a week he spoke for the chiefs. He asked the Secretary of the Interior to make an Indian, Thomas L. Sloan of the Omaha, Commissioner of Indian Affairs. The Indian Office handed back a rifle taken from him twenty years before. He went to the zoo, and heard William Jennings Bryan speak.

Around March 12 he fell ill with pneumonia. The young men of his party took him to Providence Hospital. On March 14 an old Army officer, Captain William Wilcox, brought flowers. He said Hollow Horn Bear had once saved his life.

He died early on Saturday, March 15, 1913.

Hollow Horn Bear, 64 years, Providence Hospital.

The District’s death list, Evening Star, March 16, 1913

No last words were written down. The Indian delegation wrote that his “dying expression and wish” was that Indian people be given “a voice in the administration of their own affairs.”

The funeral was the next afternoon at St. Paul’s Church, at 15th and V Streets. Every pew was filled, and the police had to clear an aisle. Six pallbearers from six nations carried him: Crow, Chippewa, Omaha, Blackfoot, Seneca and Umatilla.

That same day his body left Union Station for Rosebud, “accompanied by John Green, a Sioux Indian,” the Evening Star reported. His wife and daughters were thought to be already on their way east.

He was buried at St. Francis Mission, on Rosebud. The date has not been found.

Sources for this chapter
  • Confirmed The pipe letter. Evening Star, Feb. 3, 1913, p. 1.
  • Disputed Fort Wadsworth, Feb. 22. Program: The National American Indian Memorial (1913); Evening Star, Feb. 22 and March 2, 1913.
  • Confirmed Gill portraits, March 1, 1913. Smithsonian NAA, BAE GN 3162–3163.
  • Confirmed Wilson parade. Evening Star, March 3 and 4, 1913; Washington Herald, March 4, 1913. Probable The pipe: Day Book (Chicago), March 4, 1913.
  • Confirmed Death at Providence Hospital, March 15. Evening Star, March 15 and 16, 1913; New York Sun, March 16, 1913.
  • Confirmed Funeral and the journey home. Evening Star, March 17, 1913, p. 8.
  • Confirmed Burial at St. Francis Mission. American National Biography. Date: not found.

After

What remains

The Brulé count named the year for him.

Ten years later his face went on the stamp. In 1913 nearly every newspaper said it was already on the five-dollar bill. It was not. That note shows Running Antelope, a Hunkpapa leader. His portrait did reach money in 1970, on the ten-dollar military payment certificate printed for American troops overseas.

In 2013 his pipe came home from Little Bighorn Battlefield to his great-grandson, Duane Hollow Horn Bear. On June 12, 2021, a museum in Frankfurt, Germany, returned his shirt, held there since 1908, at a ceremony at Rosebud.

What the record corrects

Often saidThe record
His face is on the 1899 five-dollar billRunning Antelope. He was on the 1970–73 ten-dollar military certificate.
He fought in 31 battlesHis own count was 23.
He fought at the Fetterman fight, 1866He was sixteen. No early source places him there.
He was Spotted Tail’s sonHis father was Iron Shell.
The stamp was issued in 1922May 1, 1923. “1922” is the series.
He was the model for the buffalo nickelNo. The sculptor named others.
He was buried in WashingtonSt. Francis Mission, Rosebud.
He was Yankton, or OglalaSicangu, of Rosebud. The 1913 papers got it wrong.

I live right here, born right here, but I am not here as a prisoner.

Hollow Horn Bear, 1911
Sources for this chapter
  • Confirmed Winter count entry. Cheney, The Big Missouri Winter Count (1979), p. 46.
  • Confirmed The $5 note shows Running Antelope. Bureau of Engraving and Printing, 1988. $10 MPC Series 692: Hessler, Comprehensive Catalog of U.S. Paper Money.
  • Confirmed The pipe. Federal Register 78 FR 45964 (July 30, 2013).
  • Confirmed The shirt. ARTnews, July 9, 2021.

A face without a name

On May 1, 1923, the Post Office Department issued its first 14-cent stamp. The engraving came from a photograph the Smithsonian’s De Lancey Gill made in Washington on March 8, 1905. The stamp reads “American Indian.” It does not give his name.

His name was Hollow Horn Bear. He was Sicangu Lakota, of the Orphan band, the son of Iron Shell. He fought, policed, argued and travelled for his people for fifty years. He died in Washington in March 1913, a long way from Rosebud, eleven days after riding at the head of a president’s inaugural parade.

How the record spells him

The documents spell his Lakota name at least ten ways. Each one here is quoted exactly from its source. These are the record’s spellings, not the family’s.

  • Mato HehlogeceAmerican National Biography, 2000, by his great-grandson Duane Hollow Horn Bear
  • Mato HehlogecaDuane Hollow Horn Bear, quoted in The Price of a Gift, 2000
  • Matȟó HéȟloǧečaWikipedia
  • Mato-He-HlogecoSmithsonian photograph captions, 1905 and 1913
  • Matho-HexaloketcaSmithsonian photograph captions, 1905 and 1913
  • Mato-hehuloghechaDenver Public Library, Curtis portrait record
  • Mato Heli DogecaHis 1909 interview, as printed by Hardorff, 1991
  • Mato He OglogecaMary Brave Bird, Ohitika Woman, 1993
  • Mato He OklogecaHistory Nebraska photograph caption
  • MatihehlogegoSmithsonian National Postal Museum

The Buechel–Manhart Lakota Dictionary glosses hehlogeca as “hollow-horned.” Later in life he was baptized Daniel.

Sources for this chapter
  • Confirmed Issued May 1, 1923, at Washington and Muskogee; first 14¢ stamp. National Postal Museum; USPS Historian.
  • Confirmed Engraved from De Lancey Gill’s Bureau of American Ethnology negative 3159-A, March 8, 1905. Smithsonian NAA, OPPS NEG.56072; BEP News, 1989.
  • Corrected Often dated 1922, the name of the stamp series, not the issue date.

The line to today

  • Bull Tail (Sinte Tatanka), d. 1854. Chief of the Orphan band. His son: Iron Shell.
  • Iron Shell, c. 1816 – c. 1896. Leader of the Orphan band; signed the 1868 treaty. Also his son: Goes To War (c. 1855–1929).
  • Hollow Horn Bear, c. 1850 – March 15, 1913. Baptized Daniel; married Good Bed in 1874. His children: Laura (Kills in Sight, b. 1875); John (1878–1912), father of Seth Nelson (1907–1955); Henry (1881–1926); Daniel; Jennie (Swift, 1890–1968); Emily (White Hat, 1893–1957), mother of Albert White Hat Sr. (1938–2013), Lakota language teacher; Paul (b. 1896).
  • Daniel Hollow Horn Bear, June 5, 1884 – Aug. 7, 1961, born at Rosebud; married Julia Good (1889–1964) in 1908. Their children: Leah Susan (Randall, 1911–1991), Nile Paul (1913–1992), Zoe (b. 1917), Luther Louis (1919–1930), Eli (b. 1921), Raymond, Theresa Agnes (Gregg Lulow, 1931–2002).
  • Raymond Edward Hollow Horn Bear, April 19, 1925 – April 2, 1996, born at Rosebud; World War II veteran, Navy and Army. With Dorothy (Shields Him) Wright; married Nadine Like Him in 1951. His children: Anthony; Calvin F. (1952–2003).
  • Anthony Joseph Hollow Horn Bear, Jan. 13, 1946 – Feb. 12, 2003. U.S. Army; buried at Black Hills National Cemetery, Sturgis. Married Marlene Jean Feather (1936–2006). His children: Toni; John William Hollow Horn Bear (Feb. 6, 1978 – Dec. 24, 2024), enrolled member of the Rosebud Sioux Tribe, father of Haley and John Hollow Horn Bear Jr. (“JJ”).
  • Toni Hollow Horn Bear. U.S. Army veteran. Her children: Isaac, Gabrielle, Danielle and Isabelle Hollow Horn Bear.
  • Isaac Hollow Horn Bear. Software engineer; great-great-great-grandson of the chief. He made this to pay his respects, and to keep the story for the ones who come after. His children: Roman and Otaktay Hollow Horn Bear.

Living family members are named without dates.

About this page

Every statement traces to a source, listed with how sure the record is. His words reached paper through interpreters; the English is theirs. The scenes are new drawings in the style of Plains ledger art, not copies of any ledger. The winter count drawings are Battiste Good’s Brulé count as printed by Garrick Mallery in 1893. The song is the Badlands Sundance recording, used with the family’s permission.

The scenes are drawn on real ledger pages of 1863–1885 (U.S. Mint ledger, National Archives; J. H. D. Stevens ledger, North Andover Historical Society; Sarah G. N. Brown ledger, University of New Hampshire; via the Internet Archive). Red Horse’s drawings of the Little Bighorn are from the Bureau of Ethnology’s Tenth Annual Report (1893).

Terrain: USGS 3DEP, NASA SRTM, GMTED2010 and ETOPO1 via AWS Terrain Tiles. Pre-settlement vegetation: LANDFIRE Biophysical Settings (USGS, USDA Forest Service). Rivers: Natural Earth. Boundaries: US Census Bureau.

Made by a descendant who carries his name. Created by theLakotaDev.