1850–1855
Born in the smallpox winter
He was born in March 1850, by the oldest records, in country that later maps would call Sheridan County, Nebraska, near the Niobrara River. There was no Nebraska then. The territory came four years later. His great-grandson, Duane Hollow Horn Bear, gives the year as 1851, the year of the first treaty at Fort Laramie.
His father was Iron Shell, son of Bull Tail and leader of the Orphan band of the Sicangu. His mother was Wants Everything. He was one of a large family.
The keepers of the Brulé winter counts named each year for one thing that happened in it, and painted it. Battiste Good’s count names the winter he was born for the smallpox. The next winter is the “First-issue-of-goods winter”: the first annuities promised by the 1851 treaty.
Sources for this chapter
- Probable Born March 1850, Sheridan County. Hodge, Handbook of American Indians (1907), p. 557; Curtis, The North American Indian vol. 3 (1908), p. 186; his own 1909 interview (age 59).
- Disputed 1851, per American National Biography (2000), entry by Duane Hollow Horn Bear.
- Confirmed Iron Shell, son of Bull Tail, Orphan band. Bettelyoun & Waggoner, With My Own Eyes (1998), p. 154 n. 7.
- Confirmed Winter names. Mallery, Picture-Writing of the American Indians (1893), figs. 407–408.
Blue Water
On the morning of September 3, 1855, General William S. Harney’s troops attacked Little Thunder’s Brulé camp on Blue Water Creek, near Ash Hollow. Iron Shell’s camp was there.
The trader James Bordeaux had sent word twice that Harney was coming. Iron Shell told the people they would put up a white flag and talk, and he rode out with Little Thunder to meet the soldiers. By Harney’s own count, 86 Lakota were killed and about 70 women and children were taken prisoner. Battiste Good’s count says 130 died.
The youngest of Iron Shell’s three wives was taken to Fort Laramie. She was later carried east by a discharged soldier, “never to be heard from again.”
What happened to the boy is told three ways.
A family tradition
In the retreat, one baby was lost but was found by an officer and later returned to his father, Iron Shell. The baby, whose name was Hollow Horn Bear, grew up to become a great chief.
Mary Brave Bird, Ohitika Woman (1993). Also told by Hyde, Hardorff and Beck from Bettelyoun.
A captive’s account
He and his mother were captured and held at Fort Laramie until they were released in October 1855.
Josephine Waggoner, Witness (2013), p. 489, as cited by Wikipedia. Not yet checked against the book.
The officer’s account
a little child naked, save for a scarf around its waist in which a little puppy was wrapped
Lt. Richard Drum, the officer behind the rescue story, wrote in 1911 that the child was a girl, and that she later died.
Drum, Nebraska State Historical Society Collections 16 (1911), pp. 147–49.
If he was born in 1850, he was five that September, not a baby. The record does not settle it.
Sources for this chapter
- Confirmed The attack, Bordeaux’s warnings, the white flag, Harney’s figures. Bettelyoun & Waggoner (1998); Paul Beck, The First Sioux War (2004).
- Confirmed Iron Shell’s youngest wife taken and never returned. Bettelyoun & Waggoner (1998), p. 154 n. 7. Wikipedia, citing Sprague, says two wives.
- Disputed What happened to Hollow Horn Bear: three versions, above.
- Confirmed Winter name. Mallery (1893), fig. 412.